09 Apr Profit in Low Income Markets – An Oxymoron?
Let’s ask any entrepreneur the question: Why does your business exist?
Their answers will get bucketed in only two Justplainandsimple™ reasons and in this order:
1) Creating Value for the customer: Only if the customers see value, will more of them buy your products and services (n); more frequently (f) and pay you more (p). The cumulative product of these is Revenue (R) i.e. n X f X p. So, value creation is a necessary condition !!
2) Creating ROI for the Owner: If the entrepreneur does not make a return on his/her resources, there is no reason for them to be in business. Simply put, there could be other uses they can put their resources to, with better risk weighted returns.
However, one could argue, that there is another case/option of Creating Value without looking for returns. A ‘charity/donation’ framework has different implications, which may not be sustainable too. A lot of ‘not for profit’ organisations get caught in this trap. Let’s use this as an example at one end of the spectrum to demonstrate a point. The logic works like this. It is a ‘not for profit’ organisation, so profit is not an objective to be sought.
Hence, starting at the top of the P&L, fine tuning and polishing the Value Offering to yield optimal R = n X f X p loses significance. This leads to suboptimal product/service offerings coming from this sector. No wonder so many ‘charity’ organisations have gathered a connotation of sub standard offerings.
Next casualty in line is productivity. Since it is ‘not for profit’, squeezing every expense line for productivity is not key. This takes a very critical role in a ‘for profit’ organization. Hence what flows down at the base of the is ‘NO PROFIT’. From where do resources come for funding the loss or resources for growing the scale or further expansion of scope? Through donations. Sustainability is therefore affected.
What is needed to flow out, even in such an example of a ‘not for profit’, is a SURPLUS at the base of the pyramid after revenues and expenses have been churned. Whatever purpose that surplus maybe put to. Not for returns to owners, but for building scale, for reaching more beneficiaries and for further investments.
So whether we call it ‘profit’ or ‘surplus’ the significance is clear. QED. Reasonable surplus or how much is enough, is a matter for another debate related to human greed and we keep it out of the scope of this discussion for the time being. Needless to say, profit or surplus is a necessary but not sufficient condition. Therefore we have new concepts of triple bottom line coming up: profit, people and planet.
If profit is a requirement that has to be met, we get answers in the way we define it. Right in the beginning of this article, I indicated the second reason for the existence of businesses to be ‘creating ROI for the owner’.
The entrepreneur is looking for ROI. So relative ROIs from different opportunities are compared and investments made. Defining profit this way, helps us in understanding and resolving this issue creatively.
Profit cannot be made mathematically by increasing prices and cutting expenses. Pricing the product to the market is the key. More customers (n) are not going to pay more (p) or buy more frequently (f) than the value they attach to the offering.
Also, you cannot cost cut your way to glory. There will be expenses, there will be costs. Understanding ‘what adds most value to the customer’, to empathise, allows the business to focus and allocate expenses in areas that are important for value creation and hence to reap benefits of leverage and productivity. This is rewarded by the right customers (n) buying at the right frequency (f) at the right price (p).
Fundamentally, business is ‘philosophy’, not mathematics. The answer to ‘Profits in low income markets’ therefore lies in creativity and innovation. To find ways of increasing productivity, efficiency and effectiveness
JP Singh a business consultant and coach, Ennovent Pool member and ex-managing director Bausch and Lomb, South Asia. To access Mr. Singh’s expertise in business consulting, problem solving and mentoring, write to firstname.lastname@example.org